Pepper, also affectionately called Pepsi or Pepto, was a 15 hand Quarter Hors mare. She was 19 years old. Pepper was Debbie's personal horse. She was very sweet and loves her face and chest scratched. Pepsi was super sweet both on the ground and under saddle, however, she was super well trained and reacts to seat and leg cues, even those you don't intend to give. Because of this, she gets anxious with inexperienced riders on her.

Pepper was euthanized because of soundness issues, making it impossible to keep her comfortable.